Financial Analytics: Science and Experience

A methodology for evaluation of programs and practices of initiative budgeting in the regions of the Russian Federation

Vol. 10, Iss. 12, DECEMBER 2017

Received: 19 October 2017

Received in revised form: 20 November 2017

Accepted: 23 November 2017

Available online: 14 December 2017


JEL Classification: C52, H30

Pages: 1393–1406

Vagin V.V. Financial Research Institute of Ministry of Finance of Russian Federation, Moscow, Russian Federation

Gavrilova N.V. Financial Research Institute of Ministry of Finance of Russian Federation, Moscow, Russian Federation

Importance This paper deals with the issues of methodology for evaluation of programs and practices of initiative budgeting in the regions of the Russian Federation.
Objectives The goal of the article is to elaborate appropriate evaluation instruments.
Methods The study uses the analysis and classification of parameters of initiative budgeting practices.
Results The authors propose a logical model of social changes related to the implementation of initiative budgeting projects. Special attention is paid to the effects of initiative budgeting. Three groups of effects have been singled out: managerial, economic and social. Each group proposes from two to six effects.
Conclusions and Relevance Evaluation may base on a comparative analysis of indicators in municipal entities and subjects. It also may base on an analysis of the dynamics before the launch of project and several years after in same municipal entity or subject.

Keywords: initiative budgeting, methodology, evaluation, effect, participatory budgeting


  1. Vagin V.V. [Theoretical Aspects of Development Initiative Budgeting in the Russian Federation]. Finansovyi zhurnal = Financial Journal, 2016, no. 3, pp. 105–114. URL: Link (In Russ.)
  2. Shul'ga I., Sukhova A., Khachatryan G. Programma podderzhki mestnykh initsiativ v Rossii: itogi realizatsii i faktory uspekha [Local initiatives support program in Russia: realization results and success factors]. Moscow, The World Bank Publ., 2015, 4 p.
  3. Shul'ga I.E., Vagin V.V. et al. Initsiativnoe byudzhetirovanie. Rossiiskii opyt v oblasti uchastiya grazhdan v reshenii voprosov mestnogo znacheniya [Proactive budgeting. Russian experience in the field of citizen participation in matters of local importance]. Moscow, Aleks Publ., 2017, 124 p.
  4. 15 Key Metrics for Evaluating Participatory Budgeting. The Participatory Budgeting Project, New York, 2016. URL: Link
  5. Dias N. Hope for Democracy. 25 Years of Participatory Budgeting Worldwide. To In Loco Association, 2014, pp. 21–28. URL: Link downloads/Studie_Hope_for_democracy_-_25_years_of_participatory_budgeting_worldwide.pdf
  6. Sintomer Y., Herzberg C., Allegretti G. Learning from the South: Participatory Budgeting Worldwide – an Invitation to Global Cooperation. Updated Version. Bonn, InWEnt gGmbH, 2013, p. 27.
  7. Sintomer Y., Herzberg C., Röcke A. et al. Transnational Models of Citizen Participation: The Case of Participatory Budgeting. Journal of Public Deliberation, 2012, vol. 8. iss. 2, pp. 1–34.
  8. Fishkin J.S. The Voice of the People. Public Opinion and Democracy. New Haven and London, Yale University Press, 1997, 252 p.
  9. Shah A. Participatory Budgeting. Washington, D.C., World Bank, 2007, 300 p. URL: Link
  10. Gret M., Sintomer Y. The Porto Alegre Experiment. Learning Lessons for a Better Democracy. London, Zed-Books, 2005, 141 p.
  11. Keblowski W., van Criekinger M. Participatory Budgeting Polish-Style. What Kind of Policy Practice Has Travelled to Sopot, Poland? Hope for Democracy. In Loco Association, 2014, p. 369. URL: Link
  12. Khachatryan G., Shul'ga I., Gridin S. et al. Operatsionnoe rukovodstvo praktiki initsiativnogo byudzhetirovaniya: primer Programmy podderzhki mestnykh initsiativ [Project operational practice of initiative budgeting: an example of the Local Initiatives Support Program]. Moscow, Aleks Publ., 2016, 88 p.
  13. Shapovalova N.A. [Information support of the development of initiative budgeting in the Russian Federation]. Menedzhment i biznes-administrirovanie = Management and Business Administration, 2017, no. 3, pp. 31–47. (In Russ.)
  14. Antsyferova I.S. [Participation of citizens in the development of formats of the initiative (participatory) budgeting]. Obshchestvo: sotsiologiya, psikhologiya, pedagogika = Society: Sociology, Psychology, Pedagogics, 2016, no. 12, pp. 48–50. URL: Link (In Russ.)
  15. Gertler P.J., Martinez S. et al. Impact Evaluation in Practice – Second Edition. The World Bank. Washington DC, 2011.
  16. Belenchuk A.A., Lavrov A.M. [Establishment of the National System of Quality Assessment in Public Finance Management]. Nauchno-issledovatel'skii finansovyi institut. Finansovyi zhurnal = Financial Journal, 2016, no. 2, pp. 7–27. URL: Link FILES/Journal/Archive/2016/2/fm_2016_2.pdf (In Russ.)
  17. Nazarov V.S., Bogacheva O.V., Fokina T.V. [The Role of Legislative Authorities in Consideration and Adoption of the Draft Budget Law]. Nauchno-issledovatel'skii finansovyi institut. Finansovyi zhurnal = Financial Journal, 2014, no. 4, pp. 55–65. URL: Link FILES/Journal/Archive/2014/4/fm_2014_4.pdf (In Russ.)

View all articles of issue


ISSN 2311-8768 (Online)
ISSN 2073-4484 (Print)

Journal current issue

Vol. 11, Iss. 4
December 2018